The United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit has upheld Illinois' nuclear subsidy program (ZECs), finding that the program does not intrude on FERC's jurisdiction over interstate sales.

While the Illinois law did not affect the competitive retail market, as it was implemented via nonbypassable charge, the Court's reasoning is applicable in similar situations (present or future) in which the subsidy is placed on the generation side of the bill and imposed on retail suppliers (New York)

The Court distinguished the Illinois nuclear law from an earlier Maryland law providing subsidies to new capacity noting that the Illinois law does not require the nuclear plants to clear the capacity market.

"So long as a State does not condition payment of funds on capacity clearing the [inter- state] auction, the State’s program [does] not suffer from the fatal defect that renders Maryland’s program unacceptable," the Court said

Regarding commerce clause arguments, the Court said, "Illinois has not engaged in any discrimination beyond what is required by the rule that a state must regulate within its borders. All carbon-emitting plants in Illinois need to buy credits. The subsidy’s recipients are in Illinois; so are the payors. The price effect of the statute is felt wherever the power is used. All power (from inside and outside Illinois) goes for the same price in an interstate auction. The cross-subsidy among producers may injure investors in carbon-releasing plants, but only those plants in Illinois (for the state’s regulatory power stops at the border). The combination of §824(b)(1) and the absence of overt discrimination defeats any constitutional challenge to the state’s legislation."

See the opinion here

Tags:
Illinois   Nuclear   FERC   Wholesale  

Comment on this story


ADVERTISEMENT
NEW Jobs on RetailEnergyJobs.com
TPV-SALES-EXECUTIVE -- Back Office Provider -- Other
Sr-Market-Risk-Analyst -- Wholesale Supplier/Trader -- New York - New York City Metro
Head-of-Retail-Operations -- Wholesale Supplier/Trader -- Other
Energy-Regulatory-Specialist -- Other -- Other
More Stories on RetailEnergyX.com:
FERC Orders $230 Million In Penalties Against GreenHat, Related Parties '
UK Retail Supplier With US Affiliate In Talks To Secure 'New Funding'; Wholesale Prices Challenge
FERC Issues Show Cause Order To GreenHat With Proposed $229 Million Fine For Alleged 'Manipulation'
Southeast Utilities Propose Centralized Intra-Hour Wholesale Electricity Exchange Market
Illinois PIRG Recommends Forcing Exelon To Divest From ComEd, Requiring ComEd TOU Supply Rates